Edinburgh Fringe 2023: Soloists of the Scottish Chamber Orchestra series – Su-a Lee with Hamish Napier

An absolute gem in this year’s Fringe, this concert showed what fun can be had through creativity and musical collaboration, particularly when the musicians have such admiration and respect for one another as these two: Su a Lee, Assistant-Principal Cellist with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra, well known for her versatility in many genres of music and Hamish Napier, whom she introduced as one of Scotland’s most talented folk musicians and a composer, who also happens to be her husband.

On Saturday afternoon in a packed Northesk Parish Church in Musselburgh, Su-a and Hamish brought us a melding of different styles of music. Scottish folk songs and Hamish’s original compositions were interspersed with the six movements of Bach’s first cello suite.

Su-a Lee opened the concert with a piece for solo cello – an arrangement of Burns’ Ae Fond Kiss by the late Kevin McCrae, her fondly remembered friend and colleague from the SCO, who had introduced Su-a to Scottish traditional music, many years ago. After beginning simply, Kevin’s arrangement weaves the melody into an undulating line, reminiscent of the Prelude from Bach’s first suite. Su-a followed this with that prelude, playing with a wonderful lightness of touch and an airiness in the phrasing.

Hamish then joined the stage at the piano to play two strathspeys with Su-a, including one of his own. The strathspey is a traditional dance style originating from Hamish’s beloved Speyside, where he spent his childhood and now lives. He explained how the landscape of this area inspires many of his compositions. Hamish too, is a versatile musician: singer, pianist and flautist. I was struck by his eloquent voice in Burns’ Silver Tassie and his flute playing in another of his compositions, a hornpipe called The Wee Plank which came with a story involving a stash of cash hidden under a floorboard!

As the programme unfolded, we were drawn into their world as they described their home in the Cairngorms National Park where they lived during lockdown. We heard about the Scots pine under which Su-a played her cello and made several recordings. She chose a piece which Beatrice Harrison famously played outdoors accompanied by nightingales for BBC broadcasts in the 1920s: Songs My Mother Taught Me by Dvorák. The concert had been introduced as ‘impossible to categorise’ but it was still surprising to hear this romantic piece, deliciously played by the duo.

When it came to the Bach Sarabande, Su-a played unaffectedly and finished with a little run at the end that led into to Hamish’s compositions inspired by Scotland’s native trees. And then, as Su-a played the Minuets, Hamish joined in at the piano subtly at first before introducing some lush chords that would have made Bach smile. The final Bach movement for me was perfection, as Hamish seamlessly switched instruments so that flute and cello danced the Gigue together. Genius!

The audience loved it and were treated to two encores with Su-a playing … the saw (!) accompanied by Hamish at the piano. The first was a tribute to their mothers, who were in the audience, and then a piece they had played outside every week during lockdown: Somewhere over the Rainbow. This was astonishing – that a saw can produce such a musical sound – well it can when Su-a is playing it.

The whole programme was crafted so well and played so beautifully, the rapport between them shared so generously that you couldn’t help but come away smiling almost as much as Su-a!

A Song from my Childhood

Listen with Liv: where I share my musical choice of the month.

December is traditionally a time of year for many families to get together and for me that means reminiscing about a time when we had large gatherings with lots of great-aunts and uncles and two sittings for dinner. Looking back, we (my siblings and cousins) were often asked to perform for the grown ups – sing a song or play the piano. I was happy to play for my grandma who always gave me a shilling afterwards but most of us were a bit too shy in front of all the relatives and preferred when they sang or played for us. One of the songs the grown ups sang for us to dance to, when we were little, was Dance to your Daddy. Why this song I am not sure, as we have no connection with fishing, as far as I know, though my maternal grandmother’s family did come from Whitby, a fishing town on the north east coast of England. 

I love this brilliant version of the song, with fiddle and guitar, by award winning duo: Nancy Kerr and James Fagan. It was recorded at Bath Folk Festival in 2013 and is my choice this month for Listen with Liv.

The Folk Train

How would you like to go back to the days when train travel was an exciting adventure? Travelling somewhere new, you could watch the scenery, chat to fellow passengers and perhaps meet someone interesting. Put away your phone, what you need is a journey with live music. Where could you find such a phenomenon? Try Sheffield!

Try the 19.14 from Sheffield to Manchester on the fourth Tuesday of the month. It’s not any old train. It’s the Folk Train! Musicians sing and play alongside the crowd of regular commuters and folk music enthusiasts on a good-humoured, friendly journey. I was there in 2009 with a group of student ethnomusicologists*. This was our introduction to fieldwork. The band sang and played to a packed carriage, and when we reached Edale, a village in the Peak District surrounded by lush, green countryside, the musicians, followers and our lot got out and went to the pub. What better way to motivate a bunch of students! 

Folk Train small

The music continued at The Rambler Inn. It was a warm evening and the band played in the open air, a happy throng spilling out of the bar to enjoy the tunes against the backdrop of the hills. At about twenty past nine, we walked the few yards back to the station platform and all piled back on to the train for more music all the way back to Sheffield. What an entertaining introduction to fieldwork and to the music-making of this friendly city.

Folk Train1 small

I would love to go back one day. Does anyone know the name of the band pictured here? Or do you know of any similar musical train journeys? I’d love to hear about them.

So far, I’ve heard about the Buxton Line Blues Train, the Glossop Line Folk Train and the Manchester to Hathersage Folk Train – all running from Manchester Piccadilly. 

* I was studying for the MA in World Music Studies at University of Sheffield. I would recommend this course to anyone wanting flexible part-time study of a wide-range of music. It was great fun too!

Read more like this by subscribing – scroll to the bottom of the page.